Has someone been disloyal to you? You may be entitled to financial compensation! Call now for a free consultation!
Ring, ring!
“Hello? … You say someone’s been disloyal to you? … What a rat! … Did the rat make money? … Oh, he made lots of money? Very good! All that money should be yours! … Yes! … And, while I have you on the phone, tell me, what if the rat had stayed loyal to you? … Oh. … So, if he’d stayed loyal, you really wouldn’t be any better off than you are now. … Well, never mind. Lucky for you that he was disloyal! You gotta sue him and get that money that, if he’d stayed loyal, you never would have had!”
Welcome to the first in a series of blog posts answering the question: When will a court make someone disgorge his profits to you?
The only short answer is this: We are in a murky area of the law. As for a longer answer, I am going to abandon most of my usual restraint, and I will permit myself to go down rabbit holes that seem interesting. Over the course of this series, we will spend time looking into the origin of the judiciary in England, into the historical differences between law and equity in England and in America, into recent considerations of our question by the United States Supreme Court, and, eventually, into the current state of the law in New York. I hope you find the digressions interesting.
I. What is disgorgement?
We are talking about a remedy that is usually called “disgorgement.” Since the late twentieth-century, that word has been repeated so often by lawyers and judges that they may have forgotten its ordinary English meaning. To disgorge a thing is to vomit it. The word comes from the combination of “dis-” and “gorge,” where the prefix “dis-” has the same sense that it has in the word “disbarment.” The way that a lawyer is disbarred, that’s how a thing is disgorged. They are both expelled.[1] The lawyer is expelled from the bar. The thing is expelled from the throat (the “gorge”). When you are awarded the remedy of disgorgement against the disloyal rat, you make him vomit his profits.
II. There are statutes that make disgorgement, or the equivalent, available as a remedy.
Statutory law is the laws that are just a writing over which Congress or a state legislature has waived its magic wand or done whatever the legislature needs to do to make those written words into a law. When statutory law is what matters, our question about disgorgement should be easy. If the legislature wants to give you a disgorgement remedy, then the legislature can do that. And legislatures have done it lots of times. Here are examples.
Congress has said that a copyright owner can make an infringer give up any profits: “The copyright owner is entitled to recover the actual damages suffered by him or her as a result of the infringement, and any profits of the infringer that are attributable to the infringement and are not taken into account in computing the actual damages. In establishing the infringer's profits, the copyright owner is required to present proof only of the infringer’s gross revenue, and the infringer is required to prove his or her deductible expenses and the elements of profit attributable to factors other than the copyrighted work.”[2]
Congress has said that a trademark owner can make an infringer give up any profits: “When a violation of any right of the registrant of a mark registered in the Patent and Trademark Office … shall have been established …, the plaintiff shall be entitled … to recover (1) defendant’s profits, (2) any damages sustained by the plaintiff, and (3) the costs of the action. The court shall assess such profits and damages or cause the same to be assessed under its direction. In assessing profits the plaintiff shall be required to prove defendant’s sales only; defendant must prove all elements of cost or deduction claimed.”[3]
Congress has said that a design patent owner can make an infringer give up any profits: “Whoever during the term of a patent for a design, without license of the owner, (1) applies the patented design, or any colorable imitation thereof, to any article of manufacture for the purpose of sale, or (2) sells or exposes for sale any article of manufacture to which such design or colorable imitation has been applied shall be liable to the owner to the extent of his total profit….”[4]
Congress has said public companies can make the directors and officers who sell shares in the company within six months of buying the shares give up any profits: “For the purpose of preventing the unfair use of information which may have been obtained by … [a] director[] or officer by reason of his relationship to the issuer, any profit realized by him from any purchase and sale, or any sale and purchase, of any equity security of such issuer … within any period of less than six months, … shall inure to and be recoverable by the issuer ….”[5]
The New York State Legislature has said you can make someone who has wrongly held your real estate from you give up any profits made by renting it out: “In an action to recover the possession of real property, the plaintiff may recover damages for withholding the property, including the rents and profits or the value of the use and occupation of the property ….”[6]
So, if you’re suing someone for a claim that a statute gives you against that person, then read the statute to see whether your victory will mean that you can get the bad guy’s profits disgorged.
III. But our question is about law that is not a statute.
In systems of law descended from England, like we have in the United States, you often might sue someone on a claim that is not given to you by any statute. An example is a claim that someone who owed you loyalty was disloyal. That’s a standard claim for breach of a fiduciary duty. No statute gives you that claim. This is unwritten law. When will a court make someone disgorge his profits to you for that?
To talk about this, we start by going back to basics. Our claims that are not given by any statute fall into two groups: claims at law and claims in equity. This matters because it’s usually said that disgorgement is a remedy you can get, if at all, for a claim in equity, not for a claim at law. So, let’s get clear on the difference between law and equity.
The next post in this series will begin explaining the difference between law and equity.
[1] Oxford English Dictionary, “dis- prefix” (“To turn out, put out, expel, or dislodge from the place or receptacle implied”); Unabridged Merriam-Webster Dictionary, “disgorge” (“to discharge by the throat and mouth : VOMIT”).
[2] 17 U.S.C. § 504. Note how different this is from the remedy you could get, if, for example, you and a rival author agreed not to copy each other’s writings, he violated your agreement, and then you sued under contract law. Expect your remedy for breach of contract would be a damages award of around zero dollars, because your agreement was not that you would receive anything of value.
[3] 15 U.S.C. § 1117.
[4] 35 U.S.C. § 289.
[5] 15 U.S.C. § 78p(b). The statute says that it doesn’t matter if the director or officer had intended to hold the shares for longer than six months, and that any of the company’s shareholders can bring these suits in the company’s name. An owner of over 10% of the shares has the same liability as do directors and officers here.
[6] NY RPAPL 601.